Results: Combinatorics REGS 2010
This page summarizes results obtained on the problems presented in the
Summer 2010 Combinatorics REGS program. Problems are numbered as on
the REGS index page.
- Mixed Ramsey theory
- Consequences of the Berge-Fulkerson Conjecture
- Largest graphs having p perfect matchings
(Hartke, Stolee, West, Yancey) For any fixed p, there is an
n-vertex graph with more than n²/4 edges that has exactly
p perfect matchings. In particular, letting f(n,p) be the
maximum number of edges in an n-vertex graph having exactly p
perfect matchings, they proved that f(n,p)&ge n²/4+cp
for sufficiently large n, with cp being at least the
number of 1s in the binary representation of p-1. Although it is not
known whether cp is monotonic in p, the values of
cp can be as large as O(ln p / ln ln p)².
- Realizing degree lists with few perfect
matchings(O, West) To gain some insight on the problem, it may be helpful
to know the maximum number of edges in a graph with minimum degree d
that has no perfect matching. More generally, we have determined the
n-vertex graphs of minimum degree d that
have the most edges among those not having a matching of size (n-a)/2,
where a has the same parity as n.
- Total bar visibility number
- On-line Chain-Partitioning for Semiorders
(Biró, Kinnersley, Milans, Hannasch, Zamani) Let f(w) be the
minimum number of colors that suffice for Algorithm to color points in on-line
fashion when Spoiler is restricted to w points in any half-open interval.
For α∈(0,1], let fα(w) denote the
sufficient number of colors when Spoiler is further restricted to place points
only at multiples of α. As α decreases toward 0,
fα(w) increases. For all w, there exists
α such that fα(w)=f(w). For particular
α, it has been shown that f1/2(w)=w and
5w/4 ≤ f1/3(w) ≤ 3(w+1)/2.
- Tournaments and generalized score sequences
The question of characterizing FIFA score lists when the numbers of wins,
losses, and ties for each team are known reduces to characterizing degree
lists for oriented graphs. Given any realization of the wins and losses, the
missing edges will always yield a realization of the ties, since for each team
#ties = (n-1) - (#wins + #losses) = (n-1) - (out-degree +
in-degree). Thus it suffices to check that the (win,loss) list is realizable
by an oriented graph (and that in fact for each team #wins + #losses + #ties =
n-1).
- Lines tangent to four unit balls
- Fractional dimension of posets
- 2-domination and annihilation number
- Universal cycles for permutations (stub)
- Coloring a graph with no H-minor
- b-coloring in regular graphs
- Reconstruction of posets from ideal sizes
(Biro, Hartke, Isaak, McDonald, Stolee, West) Reconstruction of trees from ideal
sizes is equivalent to reconstruction of forests. For trees, the rank-sizes are
reconstructible, as are the bottom three levels of the tree. It is well-known
that the pairs (|upset|,|downset|), given for just the individual elements,
determine the poset within the family of interval orders.
- 3-cordial colorings
(Many authors) The following classes of graphs are 3-cordial: forests,
connected unicyclic graphs, and any cartesian product of any number of paths.
The latter uses a theorem that if G and H are 3-cordial, and the
number of vertices or the number of edges of G or H is divisible
by 3, then the cartesian product of G and H is 3-cordial. It is
almost certainly also true that graphs in which each component is unicyclic are
3-cordial, but this has not been completed.
Pechenik and Wise studied Z2²-cordial colorings.
They showed that all paths except P4 and
P5 have such colorings, and all cycles with lengths other
than 4, 5, and odd multiples of 2 have such colorings. Also, hypercubes
with dimension at least 3 are Z2²-cordial.
Pechenik studied A-cordial colorings for various groups A. For
fixed A, he showed that there are infinitely many A-cordial
cycles and infinitely many A-cordial paths. If A has order
n, then the complete k-partite graph having kn^2 vertices
and partite sets of size n² is A-cordial for k>2.
When A is not abelian, corresponding results hold for appropriate
orientations of the graphs.
- Yao's table storage problem
(Howard, Kezdy, Milans, West - maybe others) With two probes, adaptively,
key spaces of size at least 3n-4 can be handled. In the weaker model
that makes only two simultaneous probes, at most about
2n²lgn
keys can be handled. When n=3, the maximum that can be handled in this
model is between 15 and 18 (Howard).
- Star-critical Ramsey numbers
- Ehrenfeucht-Fraissé game & subgraph isomorphs
- Edge-antipodal colorings of hypercubes
Kolb, Pechenik, and Wise gave explicit proofs that every edge-antipodal
coloring of a hypercube with at most 5 dimensions has a monochromatic path
joining antipodes. This was previously known only by computer search.
- Segment orders
- Immersion order on graphs
(Butterfield, Hartke, LeSaunier, Milans, Stolee, Wenger) This group has
studied immersion-closed families. Outerplanar graphs are those not containing
subdivisions of K4 or K2,3; they have
characterized the graphs not containing immersions of K4 or
K2,3. Also, the graphs not containing an immersion of the
kite (K4-e) are the cacti, and the graphs with maximum local
edge-connectivity bounded by k are those not containing an immersion of
the graph consisting of k-1 triangles sharing a common edges. Extremal
problems are also being studied. It is conjectured that
(t-2)[n-(t-1)/2] is the maximum number of edges in an n-vertex
graph not containing an immersion of Kt; this is true up to
t=5.
- Sorting by k-ary comparisons
(McLaughlin, McDonald?) There has been some success generalizing results of
Aigner for the binary comparison model
- Circumference of claw-free graphs (stub)
- Revolutionaries and spies
(Butterfield, Cranston, Puleo, West, Zamani) In large complete bipartite graphs,
⌈7r/10⌉ spies can protect against meetings of size 2 among
r revolutionaries, and this is sharp. There may be some extensions to
For meetings of size m, cr/m spies are enough to win, where
c = 1/(2-√2). As an upper bound when m is large, the
number of spies needed is at least 3r/(2m). Hypercubes and
generalizations of cycles are also worth studying.
- Monotone Hamiltonian paths in hypercubes
- Undirected edge geography (stub)
- Dynamic coloring
(O, Jahanbekan, Kim, Kim, ???) An r-dynamic k-coloring is a proper
coloring that uses at least min{r,d(v)} colors on the neighborhood of
each vertex v; the minimum k permitting such a coloring is the
r-dynamic chromatic number χr(G)). Note that
χ3 is 10 for the Petersen graph. The group has studied
products. If δ(G)≥r, then χr(G \box H)
≤ max{χr(G),χ(H)}. The r-dynamic chromatic
number has been computed for the cartesian product of two paths. If G is
d-regular, then χr(G) ≤ rχ(G) for large
enough d.
The dynamic chromatic number (which is just χ2(G))
was studied in REGS for planar graphs and for graphs with bounded maximum
average degree (Mad). What girth is needed to guarantee
χ2(G)≤4 when G is planar?
Girth at least 7 implies that the dynamic choice number of a planar graph
is at most 4; the proof uses discharging and is short. Sharpness is shown by
the graph obtained from a planar graph with choice number 5 by subdividing each
edge. Also, there are planar graphs with dynamic chromatic number 4 and
arbitrarily large girth.
Furthermore, the dynamic choosability is at most 4 when Mad(G)<8/3.
Sharpness is shown by subdividing each edge of K5.
More generally, if Mad(G)<4k/(k+2), then the dynamic choosability of
G is at most k.
- Erdős-Ko-Rado problem for graphs
- Linear and weak discrepancy in posets
Kevin Milans constructed posets with linear discrepancy (2-o(1))r, where
r is the maximum number of elements incomparable to a single element,
thereby disproving the conjecture of Tanenbaum, Trenk, and Fishburn.
- Disjoint maximal independent sets (stub)
- Edge-reconstruction of multigraphs
Dan McDonald et al. have proved the edge-reconstructibility of non-simple
multigraphs whose underlying simple graphs fall in any of the following
categories: Disconnected with at least two nontrivial components,
Edge-transitive, Regular, Trees. They also proved the
edge-reconstructibility of other multigraphs with certain restrictions on where
multiedges occur.
- Matching in geometric graphs
- Expandable L(2,1)-labelings
- Crossings in horizontal drawings
Yancey has improved the lower bound on the supremum of the ratio of
opt(G) to LB(G). Previously it was 13/11; his improved lower bound is 12/10.
The known upper bound is 1.2964.
- Group connectivity of graphs
- Nowhere-zero solutions to linear equations
- Chaos: toppling piles of tokens
For the normal version (win by capturing all vertices), it was already known
that Player 1 wins on Kn for all n and wins
Cn if and only if n is odd. In REGS, McLaughlin and
Reiniger showed that Player 1 wins on a tree if and only if the number of
vertices is even. Also, each player has a strategy that avoids losing until
|V(G)|-1 turns have been played. They conjecture that Player 2 wins
on Ka,b if and only if a and b are both even,
which they have proved for the cases where min{a,b}>2 and ab is
even. They ask whether the winner on the graph obtained by identifying one
vertex of G with one vertex of H is always the same as the
winner on the disjoint union G+H. Digraph analogues have been proposed.
The misere version (win by forcing the opponent to capture all vertices)
has also been studied. Others working on these problems include Hannasch,
Kinnersley, and Puleo.
- Difference graphs
- Implications between linkage properties
Hehui Wu answered both questions in the negative, by constructing an example
that gives a "no" answer to the more restricted question.
- Trail-ordered and circuit-ordered graphs (stub)
- Spatial embeddings of graphs
- Grab the Gold! - A tree-eating game
(Arroyo, Liu, Mahoney, Olsen, Work, West) Partial results toward Player 1
getting at least half the weight on trees with even order. This is true on
double-stars and on trees obtained from double-stars by subdividing all but the
central edge. Tyler Seacrest may have proved the conjecture.
- Maker-Breaker games on grids
In the game where Maker seeks the corners of a square (of any size), Maker wins
in five turns on every n-by-n grid with n≥13. This is sharp
in terms of the number of turns required. In general, if Maker seeks the
points of any "pattern" in any number of dimensions, Gallai's Theorem and a
simple strategy-stealing argument imply that he succeeds when the board is
sufficiently large. It might be worthwhile to consider the biased game, since
then the strategy-stealing argument fails. (Probably Maker still wins
against any constant bias.)
In the game where Maker seeks as large a transversal as possible on
an n-by-n board, Maker can obtain a transversal of size n in
n+1 turns when n≥5 (the results are known and slightly
different for n≤4). The result is best possible in terms of both
transversal size and number of turns needed. Maker can also obtain a
transversal of size n-1 in n-1 turns, but this would hinder his
ability to quickly obtain a transversal of size n.
- Havel-Hakimi residue and independent sets
- Quack number
Reiniger, LeSaulnier, Wenger, and West are studying the quack numbers of
complete graphs and complete bipartite graphs.
- F-saturated graphs
- Chromatic number vs. cliques
A computer search by Kolb showed that Q(9,5)=4.
- Sorting by 3-branches
- Turán problems for co-degree
- Coloring paths in trees
- Acyclic orientation game
- Monophilic graphs (stub)
- Coloring the square of the Kneser graph
(stub)